Key Takeaway
Kajal, kohl and eyeliner aren't the same thing: kohl is the traditional loose powder, kajal is its modern pencil form for the waterline, and eyeliner defines the lash line.
The short answer to kajal vs kohl vs eyeliner difference is that they are not three names for the same pencil: kohl is the original loose mineral powder used across South Asia and the Middle East for centuries, kajal is kohl's modern, wax-based pencil descendant made specifically for safe waterline use, and eyeliner is a separate polymer-based formula built to draw a defined line along the lash line or lid rather than smudge into a smoky rim.
BigBasket.pk doesn't stock traditional loose kohl or surma, because unregulated mineral powder sold in open markets can carry unsafe lead or antimony levels — instead we carry lab-formulated kajal pencils and eyeliners from ST London, Miss Rose, Zeena Cosmetics and Revolution that deliver the same smoky or defined effect without that risk.
What Is Kohl, Really?
Kohl (also called surma in South Asia) is the original eye cosmetic, used for over 5,000 years across the Middle East, North Africa and the Subcontinent. Traditionally it is a finely ground mineral powder — historically galena (lead sulfide) or antimony sulfide (stibnite) — mixed with a binder like ghee, almond oil or castor oil into a thick paste, then applied with a small metal stick called a mirwad directly onto the eyelid margin and waterline.
The appeal was never just cosmetic. In many households kohl was believed to protect eyes from sun glare and infection, and the deep grey-black smudge it left is still the reference point people mean when they say a look is "kohl-rimmed." The problem is safety: unregulated loose kohl sold in open markets can carry dangerously high lead or antimony levels, which is why most reputable retailers do not sell traditional loose kohl. If you want the same smoky, tightlined effect without the risk, a modern kajal pencil is the safer route.
What Is Kajal, and How Is It Different From Kohl?
Kajal is kohl's modern, retail-safe descendant. Instead of loose mineral powder, kajal is set into a solid pencil or twist-up stick using a wax and petroleum-jelly (or plant-oil) base, with cosmetic-grade carbon black or iron oxide pigment for colour instead of galena or antimony. It is formulated and tested specifically to be worn close to the eye, including on the waterline, which is what sets it apart from most eyeliners.
Kajal is meant to move a little — that soft, creamy texture is what lets you smudge it along the lower lash line and waterline for a smoky, sleepy-eyed finish in seconds, with no blending brush needed. The ST London Oriental Kajal Pencil (PKR 760, was PKR 810) is a good example of this format: a deep black, creamy pencil built for the waterline and lash line rather than a hard-edged lid line.
Because kajal is softer than eyeliner, it wears down faster and can smudge more through a long, humid day in Karachi — that is a trade-off for the softer look, not a flaw. If you want the smoky effect to survive a full day out, set it with translucent powder pressed lightly over the line, or reach for a waterproof formula instead.
What Is Eyeliner, and How Does It Differ From Kajal?
Eyeliner is built to do the opposite job: draw a precise, defined line along the lash line or lid, not smudge into the waterline. Where kajal relies on a soft wax base, eyeliner formulas use film-forming ingredients like acrylates copolymer or VP/VA copolymer, which dry down and "set" on the skin so the line holds its shape for hours. That is why eyeliner comes in more formats than kajal:
- Pencil eyeliner — firmer than kajal, made to hold a crisp edge on the lid; see the ST London Intense Eyeliner (PKR 980, was PKR 1200).
- Pen-style liquid eyeliner — a flexible tip for graphic lines and wings, like the Intense Eyeliner Pen (PKR 1400, was PKR 2000) or the Revolution Relove Slick Flick Eyeliner (PKR 2150, was PKR 2400).
- Waterproof matte liquid liner — built to resist Karachi's humidity and sweat, like Zeena Cosmetics Matte Eyeliner Waterproof (PKR 500, was PKR 1000).
- Budget everyday liner — for beginners practicing their line, the Miss Rose Magic Eyeliner (PKR 450, was PKR 499) is an easy starting point.
Most eyeliners are not tested or intended for the waterline the way kajal is — using a stiff, long-wear liquid liner there can feel tight, flake, or irritate the eye. Keep eyeliner on the lash line and lid, and save the waterline for kajal.
| Product | What It Is | Price (PKR) | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| ST London - Oriental Kajal Pencil | Classic Kajal Pencil | PKR 760 | Smoky waterline & smudge looks |
| ST London - Intense Eyeliner | Everyday Pencil Liner | PKR 980 | Crisp daily lash-line definition |
| Zeena Cosmetics Matte Eyeliner Waterproof | Waterproof Matte Liner | PKR 500 | Karachi humidity & long wear |
| Revolution Relove Slick Flick Eyeliner - Black | Precision Felt-Tip Liner | PKR 2,150 | Sharp wings & cat-eye looks |
| Miss Rose Magic Eyeliner | Budget Starter Liner | PKR 450 | Beginners on a budget |
| Intense Eyeliner Pen | Bold Pen-Style Liner | PKR 1,400 | Deep black graphic lines |
Prices correct as of July 2026. Cash on Delivery available across Pakistan.
Kajal vs Kohl vs Eyeliner: The Real Differences
If you only remember three things, remember this: kohl is a traditional loose mineral powder largely phased out of retail for safety reasons, kajal is its modern wax-pencil replacement made for the waterline and a smoky finish, and eyeliner is a separate polymer-based formula made to draw a defined line on the lash line or lid. They differ in base, texture, wear zone and staying power:
- Base: kohl = mineral powder plus oil or ghee; kajal = wax and petroleum jelly plus pigment; eyeliner = film-forming polymers in liquid, gel or firm-pencil form.
- Where it's applied: kohl and kajal go on the waterline and inner rim; eyeliner is applied along the outer lash line and lid, above the lashes.
- Finish: kohl and kajal give a soft, smudged, smoky rim; eyeliner gives a crisp, controlled line, wing or cat-eye.
- Wear time: kajal is designed to move and soften through the day; a good waterproof eyeliner is designed to stay put for 8-12 hours even in Karachi's heat.
- Safety regulation: commercial kajal and eyeliner sold by known brands go through cosmetic safety testing; loose, unbranded kohl or surma from open markets generally does not, which is the main reason to avoid it.
Which One Should You Actually Use?
The honest answer is that most people need both, used differently, not one instead of the other. For a quick everyday look — office, university, running errands in Lahore or Islamabad — a single pass of kajal along the waterline is often enough on its own; it's fast and forgiving. For a night out, shaadi season, or a look that needs to survive hours under lights and heat, tightline with kajal first, then define the lash line and outer corner with an eyeliner pencil or liquid liner so the shape holds even after the kajal softens.
Skin tone and eye shape matter too: on deeper, tan or wheatish skin tones common across Pakistan, a true jet-black kajal like the ST London Oriental Kajal Pencil reads richer and more visible than brown or grey shades, while a felt-tip liner such as the Revolution Relove Slick Flick gives cleaner control for winged looks on hooded or monolid eyes where a pencil can drag. In Karachi's humidity or during a sweaty commute, swap your usual kajal for a waterproof eyeliner like Zeena Cosmetics Matte Eyeliner Waterproof so the line doesn't migrate by afternoon; in the drier winter air of Lahore or Islamabad, both kajal and eyeliner tend to glide on more easily and need less touch-up.
How to Apply Each One Correctly
For kajal: pull the lower lid down gently and rest the tip against the waterline rather than digging it in, then drag it across in one smooth motion — going back and forth breaks down the tip and pulls at the delicate skin. Sharpen before each use so the point stays soft enough to glide, not so blunt that you have to press hard.
For eyeliner: rest your elbow on a flat surface for stability, and draw the line in short, connected strokes from the inner two-thirds of the lash line outward, rather than trying one continuous sweep. Pencil formulas like the ST London Intense Eyeliner can be softened slightly with body heat — warm the tip in your hand for a few seconds — for easier gliding, while a pen-style liquid liner such as the Intense Eyeliner Pen gives more precision for a wing because the tip doesn't need pressure to deposit colour.
Whichever you use, replace pencils every 6-12 months and liquid or gel liners every 3-6 months once opened — eye-area products pick up bacteria fast, and a dried-out product drags and skips rather than gliding. Buy from a source you trust for authenticity, since counterfeit kajal and eyeliner circulating in local markets can use unlisted, unsafe ingredients; every product in BigBasket.pk's makeup range ships with Cash on Delivery nationwide so you're not paying upfront for something you haven't verified.
Common Mistakes
- Buying loose "kohl" or surma from open street stalls — it's unregulated and can contain unsafe levels of lead or antimony.
- Using a stiff, long-wear liquid eyeliner on the waterline — it isn't formulated for that delicate area and can flake or irritate the eye.
- Treating "kajal" and "kohl" as the same word for the same product, when kajal is a modern, safer wax-based reformulation of traditional mineral kohl.
- Skipping waterproof formulas during Karachi's humid summers or the monsoon, then being surprised the kajal or liner "melts" by noon.
- Not replacing pencils every 6-12 months or liquid liners every 3-6 months — old eye-area products harbour bacteria and drag instead of gliding.
Shop BigBasket.pk
Products Featured in This Article
100% authentic — Cash on Delivery across Pakistan
Frequently Asked Questions
Is kajal the same as kohl?+
No. Kohl is the traditional loose mineral powder, often historically made from galena or antimony sulfide and mixed into a paste, while kajal is the modern wax or petroleum-jelly pencil version made to be safer and easier to apply. Kajal is essentially a reformulated, retail-safe kohl, not an identical product.
Can I use eyeliner instead of kajal on my waterline?+
Not ideally. Most eyeliners, whether liquid, gel or felt-tip, are formulated with film-forming polymers meant for the lash line and lid, and can feel drying or flaky on the delicate waterline. A soft kajal pencil like the ST London Oriental Kajal Pencil (PKR 760) is designed to glide on the waterline instead.
Is traditional kohl or surma safe to use in Pakistan?+
Loose kohl or surma bought from open local markets carries a real risk of high lead or antimony content since it isn't regulated, which is why BigBasket.pk does not stock traditional loose kohl. We recommend a lab-formulated kajal pencil from a known brand instead.
Which lasts longer in Karachi's heat and humidity, kajal or eyeliner?+
A waterproof, matte eyeliner formula generally outlasts a kajal in Karachi's humidity, because kajal's soft wax base is designed to smudge on purpose. For all-day wear, try a formula like Zeena Cosmetics Matte Eyeliner Waterproof (PKR 500).
What's the difference between a kajal pencil and an eyeliner pencil?+
Both look like a pencil, but a kajal pencil is softer and creamier so it smudges easily on the waterline, while an eyeliner pencil is firmer with more wax and polymer content so it holds a crisp line on the lid without smudging as fast.
Can kajal and eyeliner be used together?+
Yes, and many Pakistani makeup looks do exactly that. Line the waterline and lower lash line with a kajal like the ST London Oriental Kajal Pencil (935) for softness, then define the upper lid with an eyeliner such as the ST London Intense Eyeliner (933) or Revolution Relove Slick Flick (1002) for a sharp line or wing.
The Short Version
TL;DR: Kohl is the traditional loose mineral powder, which we don't stock for safety reasons; kajal is its modern, waterline-safe pencil version like the ST London Oriental Kajal Pencil; and eyeliner is a separate polymer-based formula for a defined lash line. Browse both in BigBasket.pk's makeup range.
Related Reading
- → Best Eyeliner in Pakistan 2026: Top Picks
- → Best Kajal in Pakistan: Price, Smudge-Proof Picks & Guide
- → Winged Eyeliner: Step-by-Step Tutorial (Pakistan)
- → Best Eyeshadow Shades for Wheatish and Tan Skin Tones
- → Waterproof Mascara in Humid Weather: Myths vs Facts
- → Best Mascara for Volume & Length in Pakistan
Share this article
Written by
BigBasket Team
Our beauty and skincare experts at BigBasket.pk write evidence-based guides tailored for Pakistan — covering the products, ingredients, and routines that work best for South Asian skin types, Pakistan's climate, and every budget.
More articles
